12 Best Baseball Games for Xbox 360 You Need to Play

Discover the best baseball games for Xbox 360, showcasing top titles that deliver thrilling gameplay, realistic graphics, and unforgettable fun.
BrandMy RatingPrice
Amazon Renewed
Budget-Friendly Pick
7.8/10
Nickelodeon
Best for Multiplayer Fun
7.4/10
2k
Best for Realism
8.0/10
Amazon Renewed
Best for Quick Play
N/A
Amazon Renewed
9.2/10

Best Baseball Games for Xbox 360

Step up to the plate as we dive into the world of the best baseball games for Xbox 360, where digital diamonds await your discovery. Whether you’re itching to swing for the fences or strategize your way to a championship, this guide delivers a curated lineup that caters to every fan's desire. Get ready to enhance your gaming experience with titles that bring the thrill of America’s pastime right to your living room.

Budget-Friendly Pick: Mlb 2K9

Mlb 2K9 Xbox360 (Renewed)
Highlights
Live Roster feature
Player-specific animations
Precision Pitching control

When it comes to finding a budget-friendly baseball game, MLB 2K9 for Xbox 360 hits a home run.

We appreciate its Live Roster feature, which keeps players and stats fresh, ensuring you’re always in tune with the latest action.

The player-specific animations add a fun layer of realism, making it enjoyable to watch your favorite players in action.

While the Precision Pitching and Swing Stick controls give you the power to fine-tune your game, the single-player mode may not satisfy those looking for multiplayer action.

Despite moderate reviews, it’s a solid pick that balances fun and affordability!

Be sure to also check out the best basketball games for ps2 for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Mlb 2K9 on Amazon

Best for Multiplayer Fun: Nicktoons MLB

Nicktoons MLB - Xbox 360
Highlights
Extensive player roster
Controller-free Kinect option
Multiple fun game modes

When it comes to baseball gaming on the Xbox 360, we believe Nicktoons MLB stands out for its multiplayer fun!

With an extensive roster of 25 beloved Nicktoons characters alongside 300+ MLB players, you'll never run out of exciting match-ups.

The game shines with multiple modes, including Quick Play and Tournament, ensuring every play session feels fresh.

Plus, the option to play controller-free with the Kinect is a unique twist—though we did notice some reported glitches.

While the commentary may wear thin, its local multiplayer feature makes it a fantastic choice for friends looking to compete in classic baseball style!

Be sure to also check out the best basketball games for wii for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Nicktoons MLB on Amazon

Best for Realism: 2K Sports MLB 2K13

MLB 2K13 - Xbox 360
Highlights
Total control pitching
Immersive My Player mode
Dynamic player performance

MLB 2K13 definitely earns its title as the Best for Realism.

Our team was thrilled with the Total Control Pitching and Hitting, making every pitch feel like a true showdown.

The immersive My Player mode allows players to rise through the ranks from the Minor Leagues to baseball stardom, truly engaging fans in the journey.

Plus, the dynamic player tendencies keep each game fresh, providing a unique experience every time.

While some might find the presentation screens a bit cluttered, the thrill of building your own franchise and chasing championships outweighs the minor flaws.

Get ready to step up to the plate!

Be sure to also check out the best baseball gloves for 5 year olds for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for 2K Sports MLB 2K13 on Amazon

Best for Quick Play: The Bigs

The Bigs - Xbox 360 (Renewed)
Highlights
Action-oriented mini-games
Create-a-player mode
Power-ups available

When it comes to quick and exhilarating baseball action on Xbox 360, The Bigs is our top pick for a reason.

This game delivers a fast-paced gaming experience with action-oriented mini-games that keep you on your toes.

Whether you’re training players or diving into exhibition modes, you’ll feel the thrill of vying for a chance at the World Series.

Plus, the creative create-a-player mode lets you customize your player to your heart’s desire.

While it may suffer from some boring gameplay and low ratings, its power-ups, like stirring up a windstorm to shake things up, add a playful twist.

Grab your controller and get ready for some fun!

Be sure to also check out the best baseball bat for self defense for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for The Bigs on Amazon

MLB 2K13

MLB 2K13 - Xbox 360 (Renewed)
Highlights
Easy for kids
Minimal wear
Well-rated by users

We were excited to dive into this disc-only baseball game for Xbox 360.

Although it comes without the original case and manual, it has been renewed with minimal wear, making it a great choice for those who appreciate value.

With the ability for 1-2 players to jump into the action, it’s perfect for quick games with friends or family.

The 4.6-star rating from its users speaks volumes about its playability, even if it has a few quirks like old rosters.

If you’re after a fun and easy baseball experience, this game is definitely worth a swing!

Be sure to also check out the best baseball card protectors for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for MLB 2K13 on Amazon

2K Baseball 2K11

Major League Baseball 2K11 - Xbox 360
Highlights
Great audio presentation
Realistic player stats
Addictive My Player mode

In the world of baseball games for Xbox 360, 2K Sports’ 2011/2012 edition delivers a solid experience that fans will appreciate.

With realistic player stats and an addictive My Player mode, it’s easy to get lost in the action.

We particularly enjoyed the fantastic audio presentation that enhances the gameplay, making every swing feel authentic.

However, be prepared to deal with some glitches in gameplay and the occasional repetitive commentary.

While it ranks well with a 3.9-star review score, the competition is limited, making this a noteworthy choice for your baseball gaming needs.

Be sure to also check out the best baseball gloves under $200 for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for 2K Baseball 2K11 on Amazon

Major League Baseball 2K12 Baseball Games for Xbox 360

Major League Baseball 2K12 - Xbox 360 (Renewed)
Highlights
Cleaned and tested
Minimal wear
Multiplayer option

When it comes to the best baseball games for Xbox 360, this renewed gem from 2K stands out for several reasons.

It's been meticulously cleaned and tested, with only minimal wear, making it ready for action.

The multiplayer option is an awesome feature for those looking to challenge friends on the field.

However, keep in mind that it comes as a disc only—no original case or manual included.

While this might not be ideal for collectors, it's a solid pick for gameplay.

With a rating of 3.9 stars, it proves that fun can be affordable, especially for seasoned players!

Be sure to also check out the best baseball eye black for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Major League Baseball 2K12 on Amazon

Major League Baseball 2K11

Major League Baseball 2K11 - Xbox 360 (Renewed)
Highlights
Affordable price
Compatible with Xbox 360
Minimal wear and tear

We’re excited to introduce this renewed baseball game that’s perfect for casual gamers and hardcore fans alike!

Priced affordably, it’s a fantastic option for the Xbox 360, allowing up to four players to join in on the fun.

While the disc arrives without its original case or manual, it’s been cleaned and tested, flaunting only minimal wear.

With a decent rating of 3.8 stars from six reviews, it’s clear that some users are enjoying their home runs.

If you're ready to slide into some digital baseball action without breaking the bank, this could be your go-to choice!

Be sure to also check out the best baseball card sets for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Major League Baseball 2K11 on Amazon

Major League Baseball 2K10

Major League Baseball 2K10 - XBOX 360 (Renewed)
Highlights
Good graphics
Simple controls
Family-friendly rating

When it comes to baseball games on Xbox 360, this title from 2K Games stands out with its great graphics and easy-to-master controls.

We love how it caters to families, making it perfect for all ages!

However, don’t expect a deep online experience, as it offers limited features and a handful of game modes to choose from.

The sound quality doesn’t quite hit a home run, either, but for casual gaming, it remains an engaging choice.

Overall, it’s a decent pick for baseball fans looking for some fun without too much complexity!

Be sure to also check out the best baseball coaching books for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Major League Baseball 2K10 on Amazon

Amazon Renewed 2K Sports Combo Pack Baseball Games for Xbox 360

2K Sports Combo Pack - MLB2K13/NBA2K13 - Xbox 360 (Renewed)
Highlights
Total Control Pitching
Dynamic Gameplay Features
Variety of Game Modes

When it comes to MLB 2K13, we’re diving into a treasure trove of baseball excitement!

This title shines with its Total Control Pitching and Hitting features, offering us a chance to finesse our skills and strategize each play like true pros.

The variety of game modes, including My Player and Postseason options, ensures that our gameplay never gets stale.

However, we must note the repetitive nature of some aspects and graphics that could use a facelift.

Still, for those seeking a solid baseball experience on Xbox 360, MLB 2K13 delivers the goods, combining fun and challenge!

Be sure to also check out the best football gloves for linebackers for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Amazon Renewed 2K Sports Combo Pack on Amazon

2K Sports

Major League Baseball 2K8 - Xbox 360
Highlights
Improved player animations
Intuitive baserunning controls
90 Minor League teams

When it comes to the best baseball games for Xbox 360, we can't overlook this gem!

With new and improved player walk-ups and exciting home run celebrations, this game truly brings each athlete to life.

The intuitive baserunning controls make it easy to view the action and take command.

Plus, having 90 Minor League teams adds a fun twist to gameplay, whether you're in Franchise or Exhibition mode.

Although we noticed some choppy animations and minor framerate issues, the experience is still enhanced by the lively commentary from Jon Miller and Hall of Famer Joe Morgan.

If you’re after a dynamic baseball experience, this title shouldn't be missed!

Be sure to also check out the best strike pack for xbox for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for 2K Sports on Amazon

2K Baseball 2K6

Major League Baseball 2K6 - Xbox 360
Highlights
Intuitive swing controls
Engaging batting interface
Great graphics quality

We’re excited to swing into the dynamic world of this baseball game for Xbox 360!

The Swing Stick mechanic elevates the gaming experience, making every swing feel intuitive and satisfying.

Timing becomes crucial as you guess the pitch location and choose your swing – it’s like being at the plate in a real game!

The graphics are stunning, truly capturing the spirit of America’s pastime.

However, we must caution you about the frustrating pitching system that can dampen your gaming spirit and the occasional game lock-ups.

While the fielding mechanics leave something to be desired, the engaging batting interface will keep you coming back for more!

Be sure to also check out the best football gloves for quarterbacks for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for 2K Baseball 2K6 on Amazon

🎯 Popular Posts

Never Miss A Post!

Sign up for free to Athletics Only and be the first to get notified about updates.

Never Miss A Post! 🎉
Subscribe to our newsletter and get the latest deals and news
  • 01Get discounts on products and memberships
  • 02Get notified about new posts, reviews and updates
subsc